Stephanie Schuster is an appellate lawyer who handles complex, cutting-edge litigation at all stages. She has argued dozens of cases, including in most US Courts of Appeals, as well as many state appellate courts. Stephanie has also tried bet-the-company cases and led the defense of mass, coordinated, and multidistrict litigation, bringing appellate-style advocacy and strategy to every phase and aspect of the case. Her practice focuses on issues spanning diverse subject areas like retail; technology; diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI); civil rights; arbitration; and constitutional law.
Stephanie is a recognized appellate lawyer and seasoned oral advocate. Clients across industries trust Stephanie to argue high-stakes motions and appeals and to lead complex litigation in the trial court. She is committed to brief-writing excellence for every client and in any forum.
Stephanie is sought for her creative and practical approach to difficult legal issues and litigation matters. Clients turn to Stephanie to defend against novel discrimination claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1981, Title II of the Civil Rights Act, the Fair Housing Act, Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Rehabilitation Act, California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act, the New York State Human Rights Law, and similar laws. In particular, Stephanie regularly defends DEI and supplier-diversity programs and litigates emerging issues that arise from the application of established laws to new technologies, including artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, autonomous vehicles, websites, and apps. She also helps clients navigate civil rights investigations by the US Department of Justice and state regulators.
Stephanie has significant experience briefing and arguing motions to compel arbitration and related interlocutory appeals under the Federal Arbitration Act. In these cases, Stephanie has litigated many questions relating to preemption and enforcing arbitration agreements against nonsignatories.
Stephanie is also committed to LGBTQ+ rights. Over the course of her career, Stephanie’s pro bono efforts have included developing business-focused amicus curiae briefs on marriage equality in the US Supreme Court and various US Courts of Appeals, representing transgender service members challenging the now-withdrawn ban on transgender persons openly serving in the US military, and obtaining asylum for a woman persecuted by Salvadoran authorities for her sexual orientation. Most recently, Stephanie represented (in the US District Court for the Western District of Kentucky, the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, and the US Supreme Court) parents and families challenging a Kentucky law prohibiting doctors from administering certain medications to transgender adolescents, contrary to the standard of care.
Stephanie is the local practice group leader for Morgan Lewis’s litigation practice in Washington, DC. She also co-leads both the firm’s DEI and Affirmative Action Task Force and LGBTQ+ Lawyer Network.
Rising Star, Appellate, Law360 (2024)
Recognized, DC Rising Star, National Law Journal (2020)
Recognized, Rising Star, Super Lawyers (2022–2024)
Recommended, Dispute resolution: Appellate: courts of appeals/Appellate: supreme courts (states and federal), The Legal 500 US (2022–2024)
Member, Appellate Editorial Advisory Board, Law360 (2020–2022)